Tuesday, August 16, 2005

Blood and treasure

I think we need to declare a moratorium on "blood and treasure." It has a good cadence, and unlike many rhetorical flights, it sounds manly and military and serious. Which is no doubt the reason pundits have latched onto it. But it's gotten to where I can't read an article on without running into it (or its flatter cousin, "lives and treasure").

One good thing about "blood and treasure" is that it forced me to look up what kind of rhetorical device it is. The Handbook of Rhetorical Devices was the first hit on Google and was exactly what I wanted. "Blood" is a synecdoche, where a part is used to stand for the whole--the "hand" in "hired hand," for example. "Treasure" is metonym, where something closely allied is substituted for the thing itself--referring to reporters as "the press" is a common example.

According to the Wikipedia (which I probably should have thought of before Google), synecdoche is a form of metonymy and is pronounced "sin-EK-duh-kee," sort of like Schenectady. In fact--and this is something only Google would tell you--there is a blog called , written by a professor of writing at Syracuse University. I bet she thinks "blood and treasure" is hackneyed, too.

Saturday, August 13, 2005

Sky High

My local paper gave "Sky High" just one and a half stars, saying that it was a poor conglomeration of "Spy Kids," "The Incredibles," and any of the "Harry Potter" movies. Well, everyone is entitled to his opinion, so I won't quibble with his rating (except to say that he's full of shit: it's a very fun movie), but the resemblance to those three movies is superficial at best. What "Sky High" is most like is a John Hughes movie. And the likeness is clearly deliberate. Apart from the obvious high school setting and in-crowd vs. outcasts theme, every song in the movies is from the 80s, and the female lead is a delicate-looking redhead cast from the Molly Ringwald mold.

I was pretty proud of myself for making this connection, but then I did a Google search on the phrases "sky high" and "John hughes." 5460 hits. Guess my insight isn't so rare.